Frugal Americans

  • Home
  • Budgeting
  • Shopping
  • Household

9 Unusual Fast-Food Scandals and Lawsuits

February 26, 2025 · Shopping
restaurant chains fast food

Come to think about it, fast-food restaurants are just like those saloons of the Wild West. There are all sorts of memorable characters and tempting vices (also known as delicious meals), but there’s also quite a sense of danger there.

At times, somebody new enters those saloon doors and saunters over to the bar. When that happens, there’s almost a completely new movement emerging.

All of a sudden, more people have had the same issue all along, but no one said a word until then.

Remember some of the most famous fast-food scandals and lawsuits? If not, here are some of the most notable ones:

Taco Bell
Photo by jasmina abdul aziz from Shutterstock

A finger found in Chili at Wendy’s

Do you remember the story from 2005? A woman “found” a human finger in her chili at Wendy’s. Unfortunately for them, this is story is quite infamous, but luckily, it turned out that it wasn’t, in fact, the fast-food chain’s fault.

The woman who found it brought that finger with her and planted it in the chili, which is even wilder than the initial accusation, come to think about it.

Her husband’s coworker had lost the finger in an industrial accident, and they conspired together to save that finger and bring to Wendy’s. The woman, named Anna Ayala, served four years in prison for this scam.

A serious beef with Taco Bell

At one point since they’re on the market, Taco Bell was hit with a class-action lawsuit that claimed that the chain’s ground beef shouldn’t qualify as “beef.”

The suit stated that Taco Bell’s beef only had 35% beef, and the rest was entirely made of filler ingredients.

That was quite a bold claim, to be honest. Naturally, Taco Bell denied it, lawyered up really good, and got the suit dropped.

They claimed that their beef was actually 88 percent. However, they did agree to adjust their own marketing endeavors and disclose even more information about the ingredients they use.

Of course, bottom line is that it would have been really nice to hear 100 percent, but I guess it’s simply not in the cards when it comes to fast-food, is it?

Tuna or not Tuna: that was the main question all along

Only a few years ago, a very similar story resulted in Subway’s favor. Back then, a California woman alleged that Subway’s tuna was made out of other stuff than actual tuna.

Subway managed to calm her allegations quite fast, claiming that they only use “100% real, wild-caught tuna.” After this, the suit was dismissed permanently.

Woman scalded by coffee at McDonald’s

Funnily or not, they even teach you this one in law school. You must have heard of this one before, even if you might not have been aware of the entire story.

Back in 1992, a case was brought against McDonald’s right after a woman suffered bad injuries when she spilled a cup of coffee from the chain in her lap.

As the 79-year-old woman, Stella Liebeck, initially offered to settle for $20,000 to cover medical expenses and the income she lost, McDonald’s was still unwilling to pay over $800. In the end, the suit went to trial.

As the jury found Mrs. Liebeck partially at fault for her injuries, it also rewarded her with almost $3 million in punitive damages.

The high price tag was mainly due to McDonald’s complete unwillingness to change its policy of serving coffee at extreme temperatures that can, in fact, cause third-degree burns.

Even if these are the risks, which the company was well aware of from the beginning, there were other 700 past reports of injury from the coffee.

In the end, the judge reduced the award by 80%, and McDonald’s and Liebeck reached a financial agreement. Ever since, McDonald’s changed their coffee temperature.

Too much ice in Starbucks’ drinks?

At one point, there was a guy who thought he was able to take on all of Starbucks by slamming them with a proper class-action suit over the amount of ice in the cups.

This guy also claimed that the coffee titan was completely robbing people of precious coffee, all because of the ice the employees were told to put into each iced drink.

A California judge rapidly dismissed it, noting in his ruling that “if children managed to find out that adding ice in a cold beverage decreases the amount of liquid they will get, the Court has really no difficulty concluding that any reasonable consumer can’t be deceived into thinking that ordering an ice tea implies receiving a cup with the greater portion of the drink as ice.”

Starbucks also pointed out that customers can try “light ice” or “extra ice,” depending on their own preference.

Carl’s can hardee take a joke

Jack in the Box made quite a tasteful commercial once. It’s true that the commercial in question might have suggested that Carl’s Jr./ Hardee’s was mainly using angus burgers made from something else than angus.

CKE Restaurants Holdings, Inc., which is the parent company of Carl’s Jr. and Hardee’s, rapidly ran to the teacher and sued Jack in the Box, asking for a corrected advertising campaign.

However, the judge failed to see in which ways the company was harmed by the ads, and denied the requested injunction to stop the ads from airing. The two companies ultimately settled out of court, even if the details weren’t made public.

Papa John

“Papa” John Schnatter started out as just your regular pizza guy. However, somewhere along the lines, things seemed to have gone completely off the rails.

Throughout his career, he was often accused of stalking and se*ual harassment, as well as using the single worst racial slur on a conference call, and claiming to have eaten 40 pizzas in 30 days.

He also said there would be a reckoning, like he is Bane or something, declaring himself as “Papa John.” Now, Papa’s owned by Todd Penegor, and in certain locations, by Shaquille O’Neal as well.

US Blue Bell Creameries Outbreak (2015)

This was one of the most severe illness outbreaks, which affected no less than ten states in the United States.

It was mainly caused by contaminated ice cream products made by Blue Bell Creameries, a very popular Texas-based ice cream company.

The outbreak resulted in no less than ten hospitalizations and three deaths, which also led to a nationwide recall of all Blue Bell products.

The outbreak was mainly caused by the bacterium Listeria monocytogenes, which was discovered in many different samples of Blue Bell ice cream products, as well as in the company’s manufacturing spots.

It is commonly believed that the contamination was provoked by improper cleaning and sanitation practices at their facilities.

spinach
Photo by Iakovleva Daria from Shutterstock

US Spinach Outbreak (2006)

This outbreak was also caused by the consumption of fresh spinach that was contaminated with E. coli O157:H7 bacteria.

The outbreak targeted people in 26 states as well as in Canada and resulted in no less than 205 confirmed cases of E.coli infection, with 102 hospitalizations and three deaths.

The wider majority of those who were affected were women, and 31 cases also registered severe kidney failure.

The source of the outbreak was traced back to a spinach-growing region in California’s Salinas Valley.

The FDA issued a warning against the consumption of fresh spinach, as well as a recall of all fresh spinach products from the targeted area.

The outbreak had a huge impact on the spinach industry, marking an estimated loss of $74 million in sales.

If you found this article useful, we also recommend checking: 7 Simple Hacks to Save 40% of Your Paycheck

Share this article

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

MOST POPULAR

  • cheapest stores in America
    We’ve Made a List of 8 Cheapest Stores in America That You Will Definitely LOVE October 2, 2023
  • steakhouse
    Here Are 5 Worst Steakhouse Chains in America January 13, 2025
  • things you should sell before retirement
    8 Things You Should Sell Before Retirement, According to Experts August 30, 2023
  • items-bottle-pollution
    These 15 Everyday Items Are Just Not Worth Buying Anymore March 12, 2024
  • dollar store secrets
    11 Secrets Dollar Stores Don’t Want You to Know August 30, 2023

TRENDING

  • Costco
    Costco Shoppers Hate These 9 Things About Costco July 26, 2024
  • steakhouse
    Here Are 5 Worst Steakhouse Chains in America January 13, 2025
  • never buy online
    5 Items You Should Never Buy Online August 22, 2024
  • generic items Costco
    5 Generic Products to Always Buy at Costco September 15, 2023
  • spend less money
    8 Things You will Notice When You Start Spending Less Money September 18, 2023

Newsletter

Get the latest posts delivered to your inbox.

Related Articles

steakhouse takeout

12 Popular Takeout Dishes in Every State

When you order takeout, do you ever wonder if your food choices are aligned with…

Read More →
questions to ask yourself before you buy something

8 Questions to Ask Yourself Before You Buy Something

Let’s talk about questions to ask yourself before you buy something! Never was it as…

Read More →
make your groceries last longer

Can You Make Your Groceries Last Longer? Yes, With These 10 Tricks

Do you know how to save more money and make your groceries last longer?  Did…

Read More →
Little-Known Credit Card Perk

6 Brilliant Little-Known Credit Card Perks You’re Missing Out On

You’ll love this list of little-known credit card perks! When most people think about credit…

Read More →
Costco

Costco Lovers Return for These 9 Products

Only a few stores serve as a true one-stop shopping destination such as Costco. The…

Read More →
Walmart Scams

6 Walmart Scams to Watch Out for in 2025

Consumer Alert: 6 Common Walmart Scams This Year Whether we’d like to admit it or…

Read More →
paying with a credit card

Think Twice Before Buying These 10 Things With Your Credit Card

Is paying with a credit card always a good idea? Credit cards can be an…

Read More →
chase points booking

6 Best Ways to Use Chase Points

Drowning in Chase points and no clue how to spend them? You can make the…

Read More →
save money while traveling vacation

12 Things You Shouldn’t Buy on A Vacation Abroad

A couple of things are more exciting, fun, and adventurous than a vacation in a…

Read More →
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Request to Know
  • Request to Delete
  • CA Private Policy

© 2026 Frugal Americans. All rights reserved.