Frugal Americans

  • Home
  • Budgeting
  • Shopping
  • Household

8 Frugal Tips to Save Up to $500 This Thanksgiving

October 9, 2023 · Household
save money on thanksgiving dinner

Inflation hasn’t gone anywhere, and we’re no strangers to the higher prices for pretty much everything, from groceries to energy and gas. Yes, that means the biggest feasts at home are going to be a lot more expensive, the Thanksgiving one included.

So, how can you save money on Thanksgiving dinner? That’s exactly what this article is about!

According to recent data, the prices of holiday staples have significantly increased, with potatoes and turkey being around 18% more expensive this year. Sweet corn is up 11%, ham is up 8%, and pumpkins are up around 2.5%.

The good news is that there are many ways to save money without sacrificing the taste or quality of your holiday meal. Here are some ways you can save money on Thanksgiving dinner and beat inflation, many of which can be combined for the ultimate celebration that doesn’t leave you in credit card debt.

Let’s get started!

save money on thanksgiving dinner
Photo by fotog razia from Shutterstock

1. Go meatless

The first entry in our article on tricks to save money on Thanksgiving dinner is to replace meat with other sources of protein. For some, this may be a big no-no, but for others, it may sound like a tempting idea.

Plant-based meals are often less expensive than meat-centric meals. Not to mention, they are more fitting if you’re having guests over who follow vegan or vegetarian diets. An interesting idea would be to replace the real bird with a tofurkey. Or you can get creative with veggie entrees like red lentil curry, creamy butternut squash pasta, mushroom pot pie, or wild rice and butternut squash bake.

Sure, going meatless will help you save money on Thanksgiving dinner, but you know what this also means? It means more room for dessert, which most of us would agree with!

2. Opt for a limited menu

Many restaurants are cutting back on their menu options due to ingredient and labor costs, so you can do that too to save money on Thanksgiving dinner. Instead of cooking multiple foods, which, let’s be honest, will probably go bad before you eat them, opt for a limited menu.

Serve up a chic, restaurant-style one that will be easier and more enjoyable all around. To make this bistro-worthy meal more elegant, print out or write a menu on cardstock that adds to your restaurant vibe. It will look great and impress your guests!

This being said, one appetizer, a soup, an entree, a side, or perhaps two, and dessert are plenty and yet super indulgent. If you’re looking for some inspiration, here’s a cooking book with plenty of ideas for holiday dinners.

3. Shop ahead and buy in bulk

Whether you choose to go meatless or opt for a limited menu, another way to save money on Thanksgiving dinner is to shop a few weeks ahead of time and buy in bulk.

A great idea would be to pair with friends or neighbors to spit an industrial-sized package of walnuts or a larger bag of potatoes to get the lower price. This way, you pay less for the ingredients and use everything that you buy, so nothing goes to waste.

Decide on your Thanksgiving menu ahead of time so you can monitor sales, then get what you need at hopefully the lowest price.

thanksgiving
Photo by Rawpixel.com from Shutterstock

4. Host a holiday potluck

No. 4 on our list of ways to save money on Thanksgiving dinner is to host a holiday potluck. This idea is both fun and so much easier on the host.

The first thing you have to do is create a shared sign-up sheet so guests can plan and organize. Make sure you do that at least a week before so everyone has enough time to come up with an idea, buy the ingredients, and cook.

Consider offering to make the fixings and turkey, and encourage your guests to bring sides, starters, and dessert. This is a nice opportunity for friends to show off their own favorite holiday dishes or for family members to prepare their renditions of traditional family recipes. Not to mention, it’s a great way to save money on Thanksgiving dinner!

5. Opt for turkey pieces

You probably already know this, but we feel like it’s our duty to remind you: You don’t have to cook a whole turkey! Of course, the first thing that comes to mind when you’re thinking about Thanksgiving is the golden turkey cooked in the oven.

However, if you want to save money on Thanksgiving dinner, you can opt for turkey pieces. Turkey breast, turkey legs, and/or turkey wings are just as delicious. Here’s a pro tip: serve exclusively drumsticks, which cost around $2 per pound, and you can portion out two per guest.

They are so easy to both roast and eat—no carving required! Moreover, you can encourage your guests to eat with their hands. Just make sure you have a roll of paper towels on standby.

Keep reading to discover other genius ways to save money on Thanksgiving dinner!

6. Cook from a meal kit

Another way to save money on Thanksgiving dinner is to cook from a meal kit. These kits are known for being thrifty, containing everything you need, and limiting food waste.

For example, last year, Purple Carrot offered a plant-based Thanksgiving feast for $75, meant to serve four people. Blue Apron offered a Thanksgiving box that served up to eight people for $99. While chances are that this year’s prices will be higher, it’s still more affordable to opt for a meal kit than to buy all the ingredients separately.

And let’s be honest, time is money, and with minimal prep, no shopping, and just enough food for the pre-set recipes, this idea may be your best bet against inflation and will help you save money on Thanksgiving dinner.

thanksgiving
Photo by FabrikaSimf from Shutterstock

7. Don’t buy new equipment

If you’re hosting for the first time, you must be nervous that things won’t go as you wish they would. So you’ll probably try to make sure everything is perfect and buy new stuff to make sure you have everything you need on hand. However, if you want to save money on Thanksgiving dinner, you may want to find some alternatives, and yes, we’re here to help you with some!

Before you spring for that specialty cake pan, roasting tray, or baster, consider borrowing. Friends and neighbors may have extras (especially if they’re not hosting), and some local sustainable stores are now lending kitchen items for free or a low-cost rental.

And let’s be honest, you don’t need a bundt pan taking up space in your kitchen for the other 364 days of the year. If you can’t find one to borrow, choose a secondhand one. Check social sharing apps like Facebook Marketplace for good deals, or post an ISO (in search of) message on NextDoor to see if some neighbor can help out with a gravy boat.

8. Be strategic about leftovers

Last but not least on our list of ways to save money on Thanksgiving dinner is to be strategic about leftovers. While you don’t know how much of everything will become leftovers, you can usually plan for the type of food you’ll have in your fridge for the next couple of days.

In other words, think of ways you can make the most of them. Have a slow cooker or stockpot ready to make a stock using the turkey bones, bread on hand for turkey sandwiches, plastic bags to freeze turkey in if you’d rather save it for after New Year’s, and eggs to scramble with leftover veggies.

If you know you won’t eat everything you’ve cooked for Thanksgiving dinner, ask your neighbors to see if they’d like a plate, or search on social media for groups to see if you can donate it to food-insecure folks in your area.

If you liked our article on frugal ways to save money on Thanksgiving dinner, you may also want to read Don’t Let Holidays Drain Your Wallet! Try These 10 Hacks Instead.

Share this article

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

MOST POPULAR

  • cheapest stores in America
    We’ve Made a List of 8 Cheapest Stores in America That You Will Definitely LOVE October 2, 2023
  • things you should sell before retirement
    8 Things You Should Sell Before Retirement, According to Experts August 30, 2023
  • steakhouse
    Here Are 5 Worst Steakhouse Chains in America January 13, 2025
  • items-bottle-pollution
    These 15 Everyday Items Are Just Not Worth Buying Anymore March 12, 2024
  • dollar store secrets
    11 Secrets Dollar Stores Don’t Want You to Know August 30, 2023

TRENDING

  • grocery store traps
    Want to Save $1,000 Monthly? Learn to Avoid These 6 Grocery Store Traps March 8, 2024
  • score discounts on clothing vacation
    Fashion on a Budget: 11 Hacks to Always Score Discounts on Clothing February 3, 2024
  • things you should always buy in bulk can
    These 12 Discontinued Canned Foods and Drinks Fans Still Crave February 7, 2025
  • Kirkland products takeout
    10 Kirkland Products You Don’t Want to Miss! August 31, 2023
  • groceries that will last
    10 Groceries That Will Last You Forever July 28, 2024

Newsletter

Get the latest posts delivered to your inbox.

Related Articles

warehouse stores

Warehouse Store Staples: 5 Things to Always Purchase There

Have you ever considered these as warehouse store staples? When it comes to warehouse stores,…

Read More →
save $50 fix

12 Household Items that Cost Less to Replace than Actually Fix

Every now and then, something around the house breaks. It’s only fair, right? Well, now…

Read More →
extend the life of kitchen utensils

11 Upkeep Tips to Extend the Life of Every Kitchen Utensil

These are the best-proven ways to extend the life of kitchen utensils according to the…

Read More →

6 Easy Ways to Make Your Furniture Last Longer

Do you know how to make your furniture last longer? We all know that good…

Read More →
kitchen knives

Can You Make Your Favorite Kitchen Knives Last Longer? 8 Tips to Try!

Do you know how to make your favorite kitchen knives last longer? Here’s how: You…

Read More →
ways to cut down on your power bill

7 Budget-Friendly Ways to Cut Down on Your Power Bill

Do you know the best ways to cut down on your power bill?  Inflation. This…

Read More →
jar store

14 Foods You Can Store in A Jar (to Save up $) + Recipes

We’re all quite familiar with the benefits of a well-stocked pantry. It’s fairly essential for…

Read More →
costco membership

Costco Membership: 5 Things That Will Pay for It in Discounts

These items are going to pay for your Costco membership through the discounts they provide!…

Read More →
things you should always buy in bulk can

These 12 Discontinued Canned Foods and Drinks Fans Still Crave

Once upon a time, whole chickens and bread came in a can, and no one…

Read More →
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Request to Know
  • Request to Delete
  • CA Private Policy

© 2026 Frugal Americans. All rights reserved.