Skip to content

Costco Steaks: 4 Worth Buying and 6 You Should Skip

An editorial ink and watercolor illustration of a fork's tines bending against a tough, dense steak.
A fork presses into a cooked top sirloin steak on a plate to test its tenderness.

Tip #10: Pre-Cut Choice Top Sirloin Steaks

Top sirloin is traditionally marketed as a lean, economical everyday steak, but Costco’s pre-sliced packages miss the mark on true value.

Top sirloin lacks the rich intramuscular marbling found in ribeyes or strip loins, which makes it inherently prone to drying out when cooked over high direct heat.

When Costco subjects these lean pre-cut sirloins to mechanical blade tenderization, moisture escapes even faster during the searing process.

Because USDA safety guidelines require cooking blade-tenderized cuts to 145°F, you are almost guaranteed a dry, tough, overcooked piece of meat.

If you want lean, affordable beef with high flavor, purchase whole sirloin caps or stick to USDA Choice flank steaks, which cook quickly and retain moisture far better when sliced across the grain.

Share this guide Facebook Pinterest Email

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The checkout-lane newsletter

Express lane: the best savings, by email

New guides on what to buy, what to skip and which bills to cut, from our editorial team. Free.

Unsubscribe with one click. We never sell your address.